Wednesday, 29 July 2015

Is Obama About to Reject Keystone?

Rumors have evidently been swirling in Washington for several days that President Obama is about to spike the Keystone XL pipeline project. One source of these rumors is Senator John Hoeven (R-ND), a key supporter of the pipeline project and not exactly one of the President's staunchest supporters. I would normally dismiss Senator Hoeven's comments yesterday on the Senate floor as just another example of the daily litany of complaints about Obama made by Republican lawmakers in the well of the House or Senate. However.....

What Does Hillary Know?

Hillary Clinton was asked specifically about Keystone XL while on the campaign trail in New Hampshire yesterday. Asked whether she supports or opposes the project, she hedged:

 

If it’s undecided when I become president, I will answer your question. This is President Obama's decision. I'm not going to second-guess him.

At first blush, this looks like a terrible bit of fence-sitting by Secretary Clinton. As she acknowledges, she was Secretary of State when the entire approval process for this project began. For some, this looked like a classic Clinton-esque fudge at an early stage of a presidential campaign. Yet, if she happens to be privy to the President's thinking about the project (not unlikely), her "hedge" actually comes across a little differently. In short, if Obama spikes the project, it will no longer be undecided if and when Hillary Clinton assumed office. My spidey senses are tingling....

Obama Really IS Serious About Climate Change

There are numerous posts on this blog in which I argue President Obama is pretty serious about having climate change be among his presidential legacies. Moreover, he has unambiguously signaled repeatedly that he intends to take action on climate change whether the Republican controlled Congress wants to go along with him or not. If the President spikes Keystone during the August Congressional recess, critics will howl that he just completed a nuclear deal with Iran that, if approved, could lift sanctions on Iranian oil exports resulting in 2 million additional barrels on a market that's already over-supplied--- that's not very friendly to the climate, is it?

It ought to be pretty obvious to anyone that linking fossil fuel extraction to the nuclear talks with Iran was a complete non-starter. So, let's focus on those things related to climate change the President can actually achieve. The major break-through for the President was the deal struck with China as both countries head to the multilateral climate change talks in Paris later this year. Critics of the accord predictably argued that it didn't go far enough and that it punted many of the toughest measures well into the future. Yet, what's really important about the pact is that two countries who regularly spar over a whole range of issues quickly came to see climate change as a problem the two nations needed to resolve jointly.

And Canada? How about its position heading into Paris (COP 21)? For years, Canada has conveniently hidden behind American inaction on climate change by saying that it would be detrimental to the economy for serious action that would put Canadian firms at a competitive disadvantage relative to their American counterparts. The Harper Government proudly touts initiatives with the United States like the "Clean Energy Dialogue" as components of their climate change strategy. Yet, Canada is truly an international laggard on climate change and has, in my view, squandered opportunities  to work collaboratively with its North American neighbors to build at least a little credibility on the file (more here and here).

If Canada Won't Do It, Perhaps Obama Will?

All of this leads me back to rumors that Obama might spike Keystone XL. Prime Minister Harper has given President Obama little political cover to approve a pipeline project America may not need for the foreseeable future. Energy markets have been turned upside down by the advent of widespread use of fracking and directional drilling to new supplies. Yet, Keystone XL has been about far more than oil or simply a piece of infrastructure for a very long time. For good or for ill, a pipeline has become a symbol of climate change. Moreover, many believe that approval of the project would simply hasten the rapid expansion of oil sands projects widely believed to be among the world's dirtiest. The President seems unwilling to approve a project that undermines his objectives for America's contribution to climate change mitigation. It's not an extra-territorial exercise of American power, as some may howl, but the effect may turn out to be the same.

Some Humble Pie: I have periodically argued here that Keystone is essentially a piece of infrastructure that will eventually be approved. I also argued that it would be punted to the next president's desk for decision sometime after January 2017 (see post). I'm wrong on both. Keystone is more than just infrastructure (although to be fair, I do acknowledge that too). It also looks like there may not be a project for the next president to approve, especially if that president happens to be Hillary Clinton.


Monday, 27 July 2015

To Drachma or Not to Drachma....

The high stakes drama in the Eurozone over Greece's financial mess has generated a lot of ink, some of it spilled here and here. While Greece and its Eurozone creditors once again went to the precipice and looked over the edge, they once again didn't like what they saw and found a way to pull themselves back from the brink. There will undoubtedly be fascinating volumes written about the brinksmanship of the first half of 2015; ascent of Alexis Tsipras and his Syriza government to power in Athens on a wave of anti-austerity populism; his July 5 referendum gambit for negotiating leverage, eventual capitulation to more austerity on worse terms than he could have had two weeks prior, and even new reporting that renegade Syriza Party members, unhappy with the capitulation, were plotting a kind of financial coup. All of it may yet cost Mr. Tsipras his job.

Yet, as I noted in my June 23 post, the Greeks faced two horrible choices; default and eventual "Grexit" from the Eurozone, or additional austerity that would likely solidify Greece's position as an economic basket-case well into the foreseeable future. It seems that the closure of Greece's banks and the imposition of capital controls concentrated a lot of minds by giving Greeks a bit of a preview of the acute pain a "Grexit" might bring about. However, opinion remains divided (including, evidently, within Mr. Tsipras' governing coalition) over whether the best option for Greece might in fact be a "Grexit." But which path is actually worse? Grexit or austerity? The answer isn't so simple.
 

Monday, 29 June 2015

SCOTUS and the POTUS Agenda

Last week was great week for the President of the United States (POTUS). It may indeed have been the best week of his entire presidency. With a little help from the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS), President Obama may have finally cemented a legacy for himself as President beyond the historical significance of him being President at all. I have been not this President's biggest fan for a number of reasons; basically a lot of sizzle, but little steak. Yet, some credit must be given here. The President's legacy as having presided over some genuinely transformative change is now secure.

There is plenty of commentary out there about this, including the story linked above, but having watched all of this closely for the past several years, I wanted to add my two (rambling) cents:

Tuesday, 23 June 2015

A Greek Tragedy is a Certainty

Update.... June 28. Buckle up. Talks between Europe (Eurozone members and the IMF) and Greece have collapsed. Greeks have lined up at ATMs around the country trying to get at their savings. The Greek government has announced a banking holiday. Where this goes is anyone's guess....





As of today, it looks as though Greece and its international creditors (the IMF and Euro Area governments) have reached a tentative arrangement that will allow Greece to meet a June 30 debt repayment deadline, avoid default, and continue on its current path of digging itself out of a deep financial hole. Yet, as the parties to this mess rush toward each successive precipice, peer over the edge, and back away again, it's difficult to see a path forward in which crisis management in the Eurozone doesn't become the default mode of operation.

What's been missing from the frenzied efforts to deal with short-run crises is a real discussion about how to fix the institutional mismatches in the Eurozone that contributed to the pickle Greece finds itself in. Assume Greece finds a way to stay in the Euro Area and dig itself out of the hole. What then?

Wednesday, 17 June 2015

U.S. Trade Policy Meltdown....

Meltdown Update.....June 24

The U.S. Senate is today expected to pass a measure granting President Obama the Fast-Track authority he has been seeking. Yet, it's very much a pyrrhic victory for the President since the final measure will reach his desk without Trade Adjustment Assistance. The Senate measure relied heavily on support from the GOP, most of whom are opposed to TAA, and many of whom have spent the better part of Obama's presidency opposing nearly everything he puts on the table. Only 13 Senate Democrats supported the bill, one the President had invested considerable time personally lobbying lawmakers.

Two other trade-related measures will be considered later this week, including Trade Adjustment Assistance, likely to be attached to an extension of a trade preferences measure for Africa. As noted below, TAA was considered separately from Fast-Track because Congressional Leadership thought it would be easier to thread together different coalitions in support of each (itself a sign of the modern challenges of trade liberalization). We'll see if this was wise, since TAA was historically seen as a way of "purchasing" additional openness by compensating the "losers" from liberalization.

This face-saving "compromise"in the Senate reinforces the challenges of contemporary trade liberalization and the strange coalitions that need to be put together to make it work. Making sense of it all requires one to tap their inner contortionist.....

Remember,..... this fight is just about authorizing negotiations. A huge fight remains if and when the President seeks Congressional approval of what he's done..... Buckle up!!!!

Wednesday, 3 June 2015

Grexit and IR Theory.... Arrgh!

Some of you may be familiar with the Monkey Cage, a scholarly blog run by the Washington Post that looks at current events through the lens of Ivory Tower research. I'm a fan, and have a link to the Monkey Cage in my blog list to the right.

In early May,


Friday, 8 May 2015

Advice for Premier Notley: The US File

There was a political earthquake in Alberta this week as Rachel Notley and the New Democratic Party ended 44 years of Tory Party dominance in Alberta. The excitement (shock for many) of victory now turns to the even larger challenge of actual governance. Premier Notley has yet to announce who will hold some of the most important portfolios in the new government, but there are several posts that will be important where the United States is concerned; Energy, Environment, International and Intergovernmental Relations (IIR), and the Premier herself.

For this blog post, I thought I'd imagine what I'd say if Premier Notley were to call seeking some advice on how to engage the United States (my invoice is in the mail).

Monday, 4 May 2015

Cry and Sigh Congress....

As many of you who read this blog know, I am a big fan of the Federalist Papers, a series of newspaper articles written by John Jay, Alexander Hamilton, and James Madison in between October 1787 and August 1788 at the height of the debate over ratification of the U.S. Constitution. Two of the most important of these are the Federalist 10 and 51 in which James Madison outlines both the challenges of designing government (No. 10) and then (along with Hamilton) offers his prescription for doing so (No. 51).

For those who care to read these two documents, the seeds of the supposed paralysis in the American political system can be found. The (in)famous separation of powers that sets up the brutal competition for authority among the three branches of government is-- brace yourselves-- all by design!!!!! I happen to be a fan of this design, in part because of its frustrating ability to short-circuit the "mischiefs of faction" (No. 10) and thwart the concentration of power (No. 51). 

One area in which the interbranch competition has frustrated many Americans is with respect to the War Powers. The so-called "Enumerated Powers" of Article I, Section 8 of the U.S. Constitution clearly states that the Congress has the sole power to declare war. Yet, Madison's division of labor over most issues in the design of the Constitution also assigns the responsibility of "Commander in Chief" of the armed forces to the President in Article II Section 2. While the Constitution manages to distribute a range of authorities across the three branches in ways that set up competition, that competition is a little different where the War Powers are concerned; Congress regularly capitulates to the President.

Wednesday, 22 April 2015

U.S. Trade Politics: Seen This Movie Before

Those of you who follow U.S. trade policy know how ugly things can sometimes get. In March of last year, I wrote a lengthy post about the conversion of Barack Obama from staunch opponent of trade liberalization to someone that had had some kind of epiphany and been reborn as a proponent of free trade (see link here).

In that post, I also foreshadowed a debate over Trade Promotion Authority that is now upon us. The U.S. Senate is poised to debate, and probably pass, a TPA bill in early may that would delegate negotiating authority to the President to complete two signature trade initiatives; the Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP) and the Trans-Atlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP). For those of you unfamiliar with how TPA actually works, I will here shamelessly plug a journal article on the subject I wrote for Diplomatic History in 2012 (I hope Oxford Journals will forgive me for posting it). I still think it's one of the better pieces I've ever written.... Once out of the Senate, a version of the TPA legislation will have to also pass the House. Regardless of the final outcome, the TPA will reveal the deep divisions in both parties over trade (link).

What's amazing is how the debates over trade policy in the United States repeatedly descend to the some of the lowest forms of populist rhetoric. The TPA debate is already part of the 2016 Presidential election campaign as candidates, declared or otherwise, are asked to go on the record regarding their support for TPA. Depending on which way the wind happens to be blowing that day, candidates will declare themselves for or against (See story). What's more troublesome is how readily some of these candidates are willing to pander to anti-trade opponents. These days, it is far safer politically to be against trade liberalization than for it. It's also intellectually lazier! It's far easier to turn to the xenophobia of blaming foreigners for labor market woes than it is to make a more sophisticated case for trade; a topic I also dealt with in my post from a year ago.

As a reminder of the kind of simplistic nonsense that gets peddled about trade liberalization, I thought I'd post here a video that I like to show my students every fall. It's not without flaws, but it makes a strong point about the politics of trade liberalization (it happens to be funny too). The video features clips from the 2008 presidential campaign. As you watch the debate over TPA unfold in the weeks ahead, you might note how often we see more of the same....


Monday, 13 April 2015

Hillary's In!

Perhaps the worst kept secret on the planet was finally made official on Sunday; Hillary Clinton is a candidate for President in 2016.

It's hard to imagine what else can be written about Clinton after a long public career that has already cemented her place in history. There will be many questions about her campaign going forward, first among them whether she has learned from the mistakes she made in 2008. Based upon the video announcing her candidacy, the answer seems to be yes; a small-scale bus tour from New York to Iowa where she stumbled badly in 2008. But other questions loom as well:

Obama at the Summit of the Americas..... Bravo!

 I have to throw a bone to the president for his performance this past weekend at the Summit of the Americas in Panama City, Panama.

A quick scroll through the posts on this blog will show that I have not been especially complementary of Obama's foreign policy. In November of last year, I suggested that Obama's foreign policy suffered from Carter Syndrome. I have also worried about the perfect storm of foreign policy problems that seemed poised to overwhelm the last years of Obama's presidency. I've been much less critical of Obama's handling of environmental policy, particularly where the controversial Keystone XL pipeline is concerned. One can certainly levy the critique that Obama has failed to live up to expectations on issues like immigration and the environment, but I think that criticism needs to be measured against the level of opposition he's faced and his evident determination to tackle climate change in the time he has left. I've also expressed considerable sympathy for the challenges Obama (or any president) faces in being the leader of the most what remains the "indispensable country."

But this past weekend, at least, I began to think about how I'll miss his combativeness and ability to speak and think extemporaneously. 

Redefining the Floor....Down

I was scrolling through some YouTube clips the other day and came across the great Seinfeld episode in which Frank Costanza invites Seinfeld...